Submittal review stamps explained

Every action submittal comes back with a review stamp, and the stamp decides what happens next: release the order, fix and resubmit, or start over. Stamp wording varies between firms (“no exceptions taken”, “make corrections noted”, “amend and resubmit”), but nearly all of them map to the same four outcomes, plus a record-only receipt for informational items.

Important

A review stamp is the design team's response under the contract. It is not a seal, it doesn't transfer design responsibility, and most stamps say the contractor remains responsible for dimensions, quantities and coordination. Review stamps record the reviewer's decision in SubmittalKit; they are not a professional seal. Your contract's review procedure always governs.

The stamps at a glance

StampWhat it meansWhat the GC does next
ApprovedNo exceptions taken. Proceed as submitted.Release fabrication or the order, distribute to the field, close the item.
Approved as notedProceed, but incorporate the reviewer's notes.Send the notes to the sub, make sure fabrication includes them, close the item. Resubmit only if the notes ask for it.
Revise and resubmitNot acceptable as submitted; corrections needed.Don't release. Send the comments to the sub, agree a resubmit date, open revision .1.
RejectedDoes not comply; a different product or approach is required.Don't release. Find out why, get a compliant submittal, and check the schedule and cost impact.
Received for recordInformational item logged; no approval decision.File it. Typical for certificates, test reports, O&M manuals and warranties.

Approved

Also written “no exceptions taken” or “reviewed”. The reviewer found nothing that conflicts with the design intent. Release the order or fabrication, get the approved copy to your superintendent and the installing sub, and close the item in your register. Keep the approved revision handy: if it's an O&M manual, warranty or certificate, it belongs in the closeout package.

Approved as noted

Also “make corrections noted” or “furnish as corrected”. The submittal is acceptable if the notes are followed: a changed finish, an added anchor, a dimension to confirm. This is the most common stamp, and the one most often mishandled. The notes are only useful if they reach the people building it. Send the marked-up copy to the sub, ask them to confirm in writing that fabrication includes the notes, and read the notes yourself: “contractor to verify in field” is a task for your superintendent, not a formality. Usually no resubmittal is needed unless a note says “resubmit for record”.

Revise and resubmit

Also “amend and resubmit” or “returned for corrections”. Something is wrong or missing: incomplete product data, wrong gauge, missing calculations, dimensions that don't match the drawings. Nothing gets ordered. The clock now matters: the corrected submission goes through another full review period, so a revise-and-resubmit on a long-lead item can push the delivery date by the review time plus however long the sub takes to fix it. This is exactly what the buffer in your back-schedule is for.

Send the comments to the sub the same day, agree a resubmit date, and open the next revision. Ask the sub to cloud or list the changes so the reviewer only needs to check what changed.

Rejected

Also “not approved” or “not accepted”. The product or approach does not meet the specification at all, often an unapproved substitution. Don't just resubmit the same thing with a cover letter. Find out what was wrong, go back to the specified product or a properly requested substitution, and check whether the new path changes cost or lead time. A rejection on a critical-path item deserves a conversation with the architect, not just a resubmittal.

Received for record

Informational submittals (certificates, test reports, installer qualifications, manufacturer's instructions) and many closeout items are not approved; they are received and filed. Logging them with a “received for record” stamp still matters: it proves they arrived and lets you find them at closeout.

How revisions work

Every resubmission of the same item gets a new revision number while the item keeps its base number. A common scheme is spec section, sequence and revision:

  • 05 12 00-001.0: structural steel shop drawings, original submission. Stamped revise and resubmit (missing connection calculations).
  • 05 12 00-001.1: first resubmittal with calculations. Stamped approved as noted.
  • Item closed. The register shows .1 as the current, approved revision; .0 and its comments stay in the history.

Never overwrite an earlier revision or reuse its number for a different item. When a dispute comes up later about what was approved and when, the revision history is the answer.

Who has the ball after each stamp

Keeping ball in court accurate in your register is what turns “where's the steel?” into a one-line answer.

Stamps in SubmittalKit

In SubmittalKit the reviewer opens a private review link (no account), reads the PDF in the browser, chooses approved, approved as noted, revise and resubmit, rejected or received for record, adds comments and can attach a marked-up PDF. The item shows Returned, the sub's link shows the new stamp with a badge, and a revise-and-resubmit or rejected stamp opens the next revision for the sub to upload. Stamped revisions can't be edited afterwards; changes always go into a new revision. Your project engineers can also record an internal stamp when the review happens outside the app.

Track every stamp and revision free

Sub upload links, reviewer links and a full revision history for every submittal, with nothing to buy.